How to compare credit repair companies & alternatives to consider

shapecharge/GettyImages; Illustration by Hunter Newton/Bankrate

If you recently applied for a loan or a credit card and received an interest rate on the higher side — or if you got denied — those are strong signs that your credit needs improvement.

Credit repair is restoring your credit health by identifying and fixing any inaccuracies that may be dragging down your score. You can do this on your own, but it requires time and dedication. Credit repair companies can handle this for you in exchange for a fee, but each company is different. Weigh your options carefully before committing.

How to compare credit repair companies

When researching credit repair companies, carefully weigh these factors to potentially avoid credit repair scams or costly mistakes. Doing so also helps you select the best service for your situation.

Process and timeline

Research the company’s process to know what to expect. Ensure you understand how long it may take to see a difference in your credit score.

Typically, companies offer a free consultation where you can get timeline estimates to decide whether their approach works for you. A poor credit score could mean a far longer timeline. You’ll likely also have to do more work on improving your money management habits.

If you only have a few items in your credit report to address, it might take significantly less time to work through the program. But if this is the case you may also be able to easily work through the items on your own.

Packages and services

Basic packages sometimes don’t include disputes to all three credit bureaus or limit the number of disputes per month.

Premium packages may provide more comprehensive dispute services that include multiple or unlimited credit disputes each month across all three main credit bureaus. They may also provide tools like credit score monitoring, identity theft protection and more in-depth customer service.

You can also explore a lower-cost alternative, such as repairing your credit on your own or a credit-building product. Evaluate the services offered thoroughly. Items like credit score monitoring may already be available through your bank.

Prices

Most credit repair companies charge a monthly subscription fee. Since credit repair is something you can do on your own for free, it’s important to determine whether you can afford the fee and if the services provided will be worth the cost.

If you decide to move forward, expect a monthly fee of $50 to $150. Fees vary by credit repair company and the level of services provided.

Cancellation policy

Credit repair can take three to six months. After that, you will likely not need your subscription anymore. Research whether there are penalties for canceling your subscription and how quickly you can suspend it once you achieve your goal.

Keep in mind that you’re not obligated to move forward with credit repair services within three business days of signing up if you reconsider — depending on the state you live in, you may have longer. Instead, you can request a cancellation in writing and avoid any fees associated with the services.

Money-back guarantee

Credit repair companies can’t guarantee results upfront. The success of any potential repairs will be dependent on whether there are actual inaccuracies in your report that can be fixed.

Ask if the company will refund any charges if you don’t see any results within a specified period. It’s equally important to know that credit repair companies are legally prohibited from collecting payment for services upfront. If you encounter this issue, move on to a more reputable option.

Reputation

The credit repair industry is full of scams. Vet a company’s track record before signing up for any services or sharing sensitive information.

You can do this by checking the company’s name on the CFPB’s Consumer Complaint Database or seeing if there are any cases opened against it with the FTC. Also look at the company’s reviews on the Better Business Bureau’s (BBB) website and Trustpilot. In most instances there will be a disgruntled customer or two even if the services provided are up to par. But if there are a large amount of negative reviews with consistent themes you may want to explore other options.

Keep an eye out for any company that tries to charge you before completing any work or recommends you enter false information on credit or loan applications.

When is it a good idea to use a credit repair company?

Working with a credit repair company can be costly and may not be the best choice for everyone so it’s a good idea to shop around and compare credit repair companies with other options.

• If you don’t have the time to do the work yourself: If independently disputing items on your credit report with the credit bureaus is not something you have the time or patience to do, hiring a reputable credit repair company can be helpful.

• If you can afford the cost: The fees charged by credit repair companies can sometimes be steep, especially compared to a no-cost DIY approach. But if you find a company charging a reasonable cost or your credit report needs a significant amount of work, it can be a good idea.

• If your credit report needs significant work: If there are many items on your credit report that need to be addressed, it may be easier to work with a credit repair company. However, if there are just a few items you can likely tackle it yourself without the expense associated with a repair company’s services.

Alternatives to credit repair

If you’d prefer not to hire a company to do the legwork for you, consider these credit repair alternatives:

• DIY credit repair: As previously mentioned, you can handle the entire process on your own and avoid the fees associated with hiring a credit repair company. It will take a little more time and effort on your part, but it will save you money.
• Focus on your payment history: Pay all your bills on time and bring any past-due accounts current, as payment history is the largest component of the credit-scoring calculation, regardless of the scoring model used.
• Meet with a credit counselor: You can connect with a professional who assesses your situation and creates a plan of action to improve your credit profile and overall financial health.
• Credit-builder loan: In some cases, credit-builder products may be a good choice. You can likely get a credit-builder loan at your local bank or credit union.
• Consolidate your debt: Roll all your debts into a loan to lower your credit utilization rate, which is another large chunk of your credit score, and simplify the repayment process. Just be sure to shop around and get the best debt consolidation rate available to you at your current score.

The bottom line

Consider all of the pros and cons of credit repair before committing. The process can cost you money or require additional commitments depending on your chosen approach. Factor in your time available, disposable income and other financial goals when weighing your options.

If you choose to have a company do the work for you, research its credit repair packages and its reputation within the space before signing up for any services. This will help you avoid unpleasant surprises and make the most of your time and money. You may also find that a credit repair alternative is more suitable for your situation.

Once your credit score is in better shape, you can apply for funding again. Just make sure to shop around for the best personal loan rates to maximize the impact and minimize the cost.